Harsh conditions within mine concentrators

Sep 9, 2024

Why selecting the right wear-resistant valves and pumps is crucial for ensuring operational efficiency?

Mining concentrator synonymous with demanding process conditions

The mining concentrator features various harsh and abrasive processes like crushing, separation, grinding, flotation, thickening, and filtration. Each area requires process equipment to withstand these demanding conditions. Pumps, valves, instrumentation, and piping are often protected with hard coatings or other materials like rubber linings to protect metal components from abrasion. An equipment supplier with an extensive installation base and experience of these concentrator sub-processes can significantly decrease the trial-and-error effect and increase the likelihood of successful installations. Each area’s process conditions may influence mine operators to choose either harder or softer materials. Both can often be successful.

Peristaltic pumps revolutionize thickener underflow pumping in mining operations

Complex mining operations meticulously orchestrate every element for optimal efficiency and safety. Thickener underflow presents challenges. Game-changing advances in peristaltic pump technology have occurred. A rubber-lined centrifugal pump is often utilized for thickener underflow pumping. Such pumps can pass large particles, produce high flow, and handle high solids. Naturally, such pumps need repair, often requiring replacement of the gland seal, suction and discharge volute liners, the casing liner, main bearings, and the rubber-lined impeller. A centrifugal pump repair involves numerous parts, requiring significant repair time. The ideal range for medium density pumped by a rubber-lined centrifugal pump is approximately 35-percent solids. If the thickener requires a higher density slurry of 55–60 percent for delivery to a filtration process, the wear rate inside the centrifugal pump may dramatically increase, significantly increasing operating costs and downtime.

Peristaltic pumps have gained popularity in mining operations for thickener underflow pumping and pumping of medium- to high-density slurries, mainly because the main wear component is a single rubber hose. Peristaltic pumps have no gland seals, so they do not require a constant flow of clean water to the gland seal. The rubber hose on a very large peristaltic pump can be replaced in a few hours, limiting downtime and costs. Peristaltic pumps are also excellent at passing large particles without damaging the rubber hose. They can pump slurries of up to 80-percent solids and experience no significantly increased wear from higher solids pumping. The two most important factors in rubber hoses’ longevity are how often the rubber is compressed, and the temperature to which the rubber is exposed. As the mining industry evolves, innovative technologies like peristaltic pumps will be vital in optimizing efficiency, reducing operating costs, and mitigating environmental impact. By embracing these advances, mining companies can stay ahead of the curve and achieve sustainable growth in a competitive global landscape. 

Many different designs of peristaltic pumps affect hose life, MTBF (mean time between failure), and operating costs. Mining operations benefit from understanding and utilizing an eccentric rolling design peristaltic pump that compresses the rubber hose only once every 360-degree revolution. Designs that compress the hose two or more times every 360-degree revolution have a shorter hose lifetime and may severely limit pumping capacity by metal shoes rubbing against the rubber hose and causing heat generation. A single compression rolling eccentric design compressing the hose only once every 360-degree revolution can result in a hose life as much as five times longer than dual compression designs of peristaltic pumps utilizing shoe compression to create the pumping effect. With the eccentric rolling design, a much smaller diameter pump can often be utilized than with the multiple compression shoe design, with a much smaller cost and space footprint.


Pictured above is a single compression eccentric rolling design peristaltic pump. This typically results in more than double the hose life than with multiple compression designed peristaltic pumps. Because the single roller design means there is no heat generation, a lower-cost smaller pump and a smaller footprint can often be utilized than with shoe designs. Compared with multiple compression shoe designs, the hose lifetime in the eccentric rolling design can be up to five times longer, reducing operating expenses incredibly.

To summarize, a peristaltic pump may be a better solution than a centrifugal pump for thickener underflow:

  • No gland seal water required
  • Very accurate at low and high flows – speed controls pump output, and flow produced is linear with speed output
  • Much simpler repair – simply replace rubber hose, and pump can resume service
  • Faster repair, limiting downtime
  • Lower operating costs
  • Positive displacement – peristaltic pump will not lose pumping capacity with increasing head requirements
  • Can handle up to 80-percent solids with virtually no increase in rubber hose wear at higher densities.

Delivering higher-density slurries from thickener underflow can have many advantages over the downstream process. Here are some of the benefits that can be achieved:

  • By pumping 80-percent versus 35-percent solids, there is a 45-percent reduction in make-up water to be reclaimed and cleaned for future reuse
  • Process piping, valves, pumps, instrumentation, and other equipment can be reduced because less volume passes through the process
  • Delivering the thickened slurry to a filtration process may enhance the filtration process may be enhanced. The filter may shorten retention time and improve the filter’s daily output, and by delivering a dry feed to the filters, the filter may achieve a drier cake
  • Achieving all these benefits means the operating and capital expense can be reduced by as much as 50 percent.

Valve selection for dense slurry isolation and control

Valves also require special consideration for utilization in heavy slurries. Many valve types can be utilized in slurry services. Pinch valves, metal seated ball valves with hard coatings complete with scraping seats and slurry knife gates, are typically utilized for extremely harsh slurries. Both have advantages and disadvantages. Knife gate valves should always be 100-percent full port in slurry services. Typically, mining concentrators utilize two knife gate valve types. One adds an extremely hard facing to the knife and seating area to withstand abrasion. The other utilizes two large rubber sleeves that are the only component in contact with the medium in the open condition. The rubber provides wear protection. These rubber sleeved knife gate valves typically have a push-through design, in which the metal gates separate the rubber sleeves as the valve is closed, allowing any collected solids at the bottom of the valve to be pushed through the rubber sleeves and discharged. The valve thus remains trouble-free. Metal knife gates with hard coatings rely on crushing through and buildup at the bottom of the valve.

Knife gate valves offer short face-to-face, lighter weight, and lower costs than metal seated ball valves and pinch valves. However, metal seated ball valves and pinch valves may offer more trouble-free operation than knife gate valves.

A high-quality pinch valve is probably the most trouble-free valve for slurry service: When the valve is fully open, it is 100-percent full port, with no areas for material to accumulate. All other valves have pockets or cavities into which solids can migrate, eventually causing difficult valve operation or even failure. Any material scaling on a pinch valve’s inner surface starts to flake as the valve begins to close and is then further cleaned as the velocity increases, and the valve closes further. Pinch valves are genuinely self-cleaning and are very successful in slurry flow or pressure control applications. Rubber sleeves can be manufactured reduced port to supply excellent control at the process’s desired flowrate and can be extremely durable in control service. When the rubber sleeve fails, it can be replaced more quickly and less expensively than in other control valve types. Pinch valves are limited to pressures up to a maximum 1,500 psig and a temperature of 320 degrees F (160 degrees C).

Pinch valves can handle slurry shut-off and control up to 80-percent solids. They are inexpensive and easy to repair. Normally, the only required part is a new rubber sleeve that can be installed onsite with no special tools and basic mechanical skills.

Push-through design knife gate valve. This push-through knife gate valve can discharge solids from the valve’s bottom to prevent material buildup in the valve. A push-through design provides trouble-free operation in high-solids slurries. It is typically available in wafer and flanged designs. Above is a flanged design.  


Ceramic ball valve with ceramic inlet and outlet and solid ceramic ball. Ideal for extremely harsh process conditions.  

Metal seated ball valves can withstand much higher pressures and temperatures than pinch valves and rubber seated knife gates. Depending on the design, a metal seated ball valve can withstand temperatures up to 1,110 degrees F (600 degrees C). This significantly extends product capabilities in services such as high-temperature steam, metal refineries, and the elution gold process. Ball valves can be equipped with solids-proof metal seats to ensure trouble-free operation. They can also be equipped with inlet and discharge ceramic liners to protect the valve body, and the ball can be of solid ceramic for extreme wear conditions. It is wise to utilize a valve with a partially stabilized zirconium (PSZ) ceramic ball and liners. This ceramic material is less susceptible to thermal and pressure escalation.

Conclusion

Mining is the harshest processing environment globally. Selecting wear-resistant valves and pumps is vital to maintain operational efficiency, ensure workers’ safety and optimize mining equipment’s lifespan. Focusing on proven technologies and established brands will probably make your operations more efficient and improve safety.

Text by Todd Loudin. For more information on Flowrox pumps, contact via e-mail markus.rossi@valmet.com

Text originally published in September issue of Global Mining Review magazine as "Tackling demanding process conditions".

Subscribe to our newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter

Subscribe now to our 'Go with the flow' newsletter and receive the latest insights directly to your email.

Subscribe

Related readings